Troubleshooting Guide for Twin Disc MG516 Marine Gear

April 1, 2025

Introduction

The Twin Disc MG516 and MG5161 marine gears are built for long-term service under continuous load, harsh marine environments, and frequent directional changes. Despite their rugged design, mechanical systems eventually wear, oil systems degrade, and electronic controls fail. This guide is engineered for fleet operators, ship engineers, and marine mechanics needing a comprehensive troubleshooting checklist and root cause analysis strategy for diagnosing MG516 issues in the field.

Parts Catalog for Twin Disc MG516 Marine Transmissions
Rebuilt Twin Disc MG516 Marine Transmissions
Plate Kit For Twin Disc MG516 Marine Transmission
Gasket Kits For Twin Disc MG516 Marine Transmission

This guide includes:

Common symptoms like no drive, slipping, or delayed engagement
Step-by-step diagnostic tips with pressure readings and performance clues
Guidance on when to call a professional technician or remanufacturer

Disclaimer: Always reference the official Twin Disc service manual for model-specific specs, tolerances, and repair procedures. This guide does not replace OEM procedures but enhances field-based diagnostics.

Common Symptoms and Causes

Let’s walk through the most reported issues with the Twin Disc MG516 and how to interpret their cause.

⚠️ 1. No Drive in Forward or Reverse

Symptom:

The transmission fails to move the vessel in either direction, despite engine RPM increasing normally.

Possible Causes:

Cause	Details
Low or no oil pressure	Hydraulic clutches cannot engage
Shift valve malfunction	Spools stuck or not receiving signal
Electrical control failure	Solenoid not receiving or transmitting signal
Broken input shaft	No torque transmission from engine
Control lever misalignment	Mechanical or cable issue
Worn clutch discs	Excessive clearance, no torque transfer
Air in system	Causes pump cavitation or foam lock

⚠️ 2. Slipping in Gear

Symptom:

Transmission engages, but RPM rises under load with no proportional movement.

Common Causes:

Cause	Explanation
Burned clutch plates	Loss of friction from heat or age
Low oil pressure	Incomplete clutch engagement
Incorrect oil viscosity	Poor hydraulic pressure buildup
Improper clutch pack clearance	Excess space = slippage
Oil contaminated with water	Lowers clutch coefficient of friction
Solenoid underperforming	Partial shift engagement

⚠️ 3. Delayed Engagement

Symptom:

Gear takes 2–5+ seconds to engage after shifting from neutral.

Root Causes:

Cause	Impact
Valve body contamination	Slows hydraulic response
Varnish on spool valves	Causes stiction
Worn or collapsed clutch piston seals	Oil leaks past seals, delaying pressure build
Low idle RPM	Inadequate pump speed
Clogged filter	Restricts oil flow to clutch control

⚠️ 4. Overheating Oil

Symptom:

Transmission oil temperature exceeds 200°F+ under normal load.

Possible Issues:

Clogged heat exchanger
Low oil level
Failed cooler water pump
Worn clutches = heat generation
Oil breakdown = high friction

⚠️ 5. No Reverse or No Forward Only

Indicates:

Single clutch pack failure
One solenoid stuck or burnt out
One valve spool stuck
Improper shift signal from control head

Diagnostic Tips: Pressure Testing and Performance Indicators

Diagnosing marine transmission issues begins with pressure testing and visual inspection. The MG516 is a hydraulically actuated gearbox, so understanding pressure behavior is key.

Step 1: Check Oil Level and Condition

Use dipstick with transmission fully warmed up
Oil should be golden or amber (not black, milky, or foamy)
Low oil = poor engagement
Milky oil = water ingress
Blackened oil = burned clutch packs
Foam = air in pump or suction line

Step 2: Read Hydraulic Pressure

Use the test port located near the valve body or filter housing.

Tools:

Hydraulic pressure gauge rated to 400–500 PSI
Adapter for test port
Infrared thermometer (optional)
Logbook for idle and loaded readings

Pressure Specifications (Typical)

Gear	PSI at Idle	PSI at Operating RPM
Neutral	15–50 PSI	20–70 PSI
Forward Engaged	250–310 PSI	280–350 PSI
Reverse Engaged	250–310 PSI	280–350 PSI

If pressure is below 200 PSI under load, the clutch will likely not engage properly.

Step 3: Shift Function Test

Warm engine to normal temp
With neutral engaged, shift to forward
Monitor engagement time (should be <2 seconds)
Repeat with reverse
Observe any delays, jerking, or surging

Step 4: Listen and Feel

“Clunk” or “click” sound = clutch pack locking properly
Long delay or no sound = clutch not engaging
Surging = air in hydraulic circuit
Vibration = misaligned shaft or worn damper plate

Step 5: Inspect Filters and Coolers

Remove and inspect oil filter
Look for metal flakes, burnt smell, or sludge
Check cooler for blockage, especially with saltwater systems
Use infrared gun to test oil temperature before and after cooler

Step 6: Check Electronic Inputs (if equipped)

EC300 or similar controller:
- Power, ground, signal continuity
- Solenoid resistance (4–12 ohms typical)
- Check for blinking fault codes
- Override shift actuator if system allows

Step 7: Check Linkage (Manual Units)

Ensure shift cable fully travels from N to F or R
Lubricate and realign lever if binding
Remove control cable and manually move valve by hand

Interpreting Pressure Behavior

Understanding pressure patterns can help you determine which component is faulty.

Pressure Behavior	Likely Cause
Low in all gears	Oil pump failure or suction air leak
Normal in FWD, low in REV	Reverse clutch issue or solenoid failure
Pressure spikes and drops	Air in system or clogged filter
Zero pressure	Pump not primed or input shaft broken
Slow pressure rise	Worn seals or sticky valve spool

When to Call a Specialist

Sometimes, even seasoned mechanics need to bring in a professional—especially when time is limited or the risk of improper reassembly is high.

Call a Twin Disc Specialist or Rebuilder If:

🔧 1. Clutch Packs Need Replacement

Clutch pack clearances must be measured to within 0.001”–0.003”
Stacking errors can cause catastrophic drag or slip
Incorrect plate types or quantity can lock up the gear

🔧 2. Gear Teeth Show Wear or Pitting

Requires magnification, backlash check, and pattern testing
Gear misalignment or bearing wear can escalate rapidly
Tooth replacement requires housing teardown

🔧 3. Bearings Need Replacement

Requires press tools or oven methods
Improper bearing preload can cause overheating
If endplay is misadjusted, shaft wear or seal failure is imminent

🔧 4. Output Shaft Alignment Fails

Misalignment > 0.004” leads to rapid wear
Precision flange tools and shimming may be needed
Prop shaft movement may need to be accounted for

🔧 5. You’re Unsure of Torque Specs

Critical bolts (e.g., flange bolts, clutch carrier) need specific torque
Over-torquing = cracked housings
Under-torquing = catastrophic loosening under load

🔧 6. Housing Is Cracked or Scored

Surface damage around bearing seats, threads, or oil galleries
Should be inspected using borescope, dye-penetrant, or x-ray in some cases
Welding or remachining castings is a specialist job

🔧 7. Transmission Has History of Overheating

Requires oil flow diagnostics, clutch rebuild, and cooler replacement
Varnish buildup in valve body may prevent full shift travel
Debris from overheated clutches can destroy new bearings and seals if not flushed

Summary Diagnostic Flowchart

markdown

CopyEdit

Is there any movement in FWD or REV?

→ No → Check oil pressure and linkage → Check pump

↓

Yes, but delayed or slipping?

→ Check clutch pressure, oil condition, and solenoids

↓

Is pressure good but still slips?

→ Inspect clutch packs and piston seals

↓

Is temperature rising?

→ Inspect filter, oil level, cooler flow

↓

Still unresolved?

→ Disassemble valve body, replace filter, flush cooler

↓

Still unresolved?

→ Rebuild or replace transmission

Real-World Troubleshooting Examples

Case 1: Charter Boat With No Drive

Issue: No movement in forward or reverse. Engine RPM OK.

Diagnosis: 0 PSI pressure. Shaft rotating = input OK.

Fix: Found pump drive gear sheared off. Replaced gear and restored oil flow. Pressure restored to 280 PSI at idle. System operational.

Case 2: Workboat with Slipping Forward

Issue: Forward engaged but RPM surged under load.

Diagnosis: Pressure held at 270 PSI. Oil black and burnt.

Fix: Clutch pack destroyed. Replaced friction and steel plates. Filter replaced. New Viton seals installed. Flushed cooler. Vessel returned to service.

Case 3: Intermittent Delay in Reverse

Issue: Random 4–6 sec delay shifting into reverse

Findings: Solenoid weak—resistance 15 ohms, should be 8.6. Spool moved sluggishly.

Fix: Replaced reverse solenoid and cleaned valve block. Shifting became instant.

Preventative Tips to Reduce Downtime

Change oil every 250 hours
Replace filters at every oil change
Flush cooler annually
Test shift solenoids quarterly
Log pressure readings every 500 hours
Keep shaft seals dry and inspect often
Align flange within 0.002” total runout

Recommended Troubleshooting Tools

Hydraulic test kit (0–500 PSI gauge, adapters)
Infrared temp gun
Oil sample extraction tool
Digital caliper
Feeler gauge set
Dial indicator for backlash
Multimeter (with ohmmeter and continuity check)
Thread locker and torque wrench

Final Takeaway: Troubleshooting the MG516 Is a Step-by-Step Process

The Twin Disc MG516 is a rugged transmission system, but any mechanical gear can fail if pushed beyond its limits—or if maintenance falls short. The key to troubleshooting is observation, measurement, and patience.

Don’t guess—test. Don’t assume—inspect. Don’t delay—repair.

Please follow and like us:

We Deliver To Your Door In Canada

24 hr Worldwide Shipping

Success!

Troubleshooting Guide for Twin Disc MG516 Marine Gear

Introduction